Which Mortgage Actually Costs Less? How to Compare Loan Options the Right Way


The cheapest loan depends on one thing most people skip: how long you'll actually keep it.
What's the best way to compare mortgage offers?
Compare the total cost of each loan over the years you plan to keep it. Total cost means interest, mortgage insurance, points and lender fees. Not the rate by itself, and not the payment by itself.
Principal and your down payment build equity, so they're not a cost. Leave them out of the comparison.
A real comparison: three options on a $950,000 home
Here's what the calculator shows for three common choices on a $950,000 purchase:
Over 7 years, buying down the rate saves about $10,500 compared with Option 1. The 10% down option costs the most, but it leaves $95,000 more in your bank account at closing.
Is paying points worth it?
Paying points is worth it if you keep the loan past the break-even point. In this example, 1.25 points costs $9,500 and lowers the payment by about $184 a month. That's a break-even of about 4 years and 4 months.
Keep the loan 7 years and the points win. Sell or refinance in 3 years and they lose. At the 3-year mark, Option 1 is actually about $900 cheaper.
That's why the timeline matters more than the rate.
Does it make sense to put less than 20% down?
Sometimes. Putting 10% down costs more over time because you borrow more and pay mortgage insurance. In this example, mortgage insurance adds up to about $20,000 over 7 years.
But cash has value too. That $95,000 you didn't put down could cover reserves, renovations, or investments. Mortgage insurance on a conventional loan also drops off once your balance reaches 78% of the original price, sooner if your home value rises and you request removal.
If you're weighing what that extra cash could grow into, see the Reinvestment Calculator.
What should I include when comparing loan estimates?
Use the same numbers for every option:
Purchase price, property taxes, insurance and HOA
Down payment percentage for each option
Rate and term for each option
Points, if any
Lender and title closing costs
Monthly mortgage insurance, if any
Then set the slider to how long you realistically expect to keep the loan. Be honest. Most people sell or refinance sooner than they plan to.
What does the chart show?
The chart tracks each loan's cost year by year. Where two lines cross is the year one option overtakes the other. If you're not sure how long you'll stay, look at which option wins across the widest range of years.
Try it with your numbers
Open the free Loan Comparison Calculator. Free, no sign-up, works on your phone.
Got loan estimates from two lenders? Send them over. I'll line them up side by side and show you where the real difference is.
Frequently asked questions
How do I compare two mortgage offers? Compare total loan cost over the years you'll keep the loan: interest, mortgage insurance, points and fees.
Is it worth paying points on a mortgage? It is if you keep the loan past the break-even. Divide the cost of the points by the monthly savings to find it.
Is 10% down or 20% down better? 20% down usually costs less over time. 10% down keeps more cash in your pocket. The calculator shows both side by side.
When does mortgage insurance go away? On conventional loans, it ends automatically when your balance reaches 78% of the original value. You can often request removal earlier.
Mike Belfor is a Branch Manager and Loan Originator with American Pacific Mortgage (NMLS 1850), with about 24 years in mortgage lending. MLO NMLS 264700, DRE 01878769.
Compare up to three mortgage options by payment, cash to close and true cost over the years you'll keep the loan. Free, no sign-up.
mortgage loan comparison calculator
is paying points worth it, compare mortgage offers, 10 percent down vs 20 percent down, mortgage points break even, loan estimate comparison






Comments